Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe

There’s just something downright comforting about this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe that instantly takes me back to my grandma’s kitchen. I remember the first time I made it for a family gathering — the rich, nutty aroma filled the house, and everyone kept sneaking bites before we even sat down. That creamy peanut butter filling layered over a crisp crust, topped with fluffy whipped cream and crunchy peanut butter crumbles? Pure magic. It’s a dessert that always wins hearts and plates instantly.

What makes this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe so special is how it balances textures and flavors perfectly. You get that smooth, luscious peanut butter pudding layered with pillowy whipped cream, contrasted with those little peanut butter crumbles that add a satisfying crunch. The vanilla pudding adds a velvety, light sweetness that keeps the pie from ever feeling too heavy. Plus, the colors — from golden crust to creamy tan filling and bright white topping — just invite you to dig in. It’s approachable enough to whip up on a weeknight yet impressive enough for holiday dinner.

If you’ve never made it before, don’t worry! This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe is beginner-friendly and uses straightforward steps that I’ll walk you through carefully. Once you get the hang of mixing the crumbles and folding the whipped cream in, you’ll see how effortless and rewarding it is. Let’s dive in and make a pie your friends and family won’t stop talking about.

Ingredients You’ll Be Working With

Before we get started, it’s best to gather all your ingredients and measure them carefully — this pie is all about that perfect balance. Don’t worry though, the full, exact amounts are clearly listed in the recipe card at the bottom so you won’t miss a thing.

• Pie crust: A 9-inch baked and cooled pie crust is the perfect base; store-bought or homemade both work well.
• Powdered sugar: Sweetens the peanut butter crumbles with a smooth finish.
• Creamy peanut butter: Adds rich flavor in both crumbles and filling; natural or regular brands are fine.
• Instant vanilla pudding mix: Helps form the luscious peanut butter filling with a quick-set texture.
• Milk: Whole milk adds creaminess, but any milk you prefer will work.
• Whipped cream or Cool Whip: Lightens the filling and tops the pie beautifully; fresh whipped cream yields best texture.

Substitutions are simple here — if you’re dairy-free, try using a dairy-free milk and whipped topping, and peanut butter can be swapped with almond butter for a twist.

Tools You’ll Need

• Electric mixer: Makes combining the peanut butter crumbles and mixing pudding filling effortless.
• Mixing bowls: A couple of medium and large bowls help keep your steps organized.
• 9-inch pie dish: Choose ceramic or glass for even cooling and a pretty presentation.
• Measuring cups and spoons: Accuracy ensures your pie sets perfectly every time.
• Spatula or spoon: For gentle folding of whipped cream into the pudding.

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe

Let’s get this pie ready! First, make sure your pie crust is baked and cooled so it’s crisp and holds all that creamy goodness. Then, we’ll put together the peanut butter crumbles and the filling in easy steps.

1. Make Peanut Butter Crumbles: In a medium bowl, use your electric mixer on medium speed to beat together powdered sugar and creamy peanut butter. You’ll see small crumbles start to form. If it seems too powdery, add a few drops of water to encourage bigger nugget formation—just don’t overdo it. Set half of these crumbles aside for the topping.
2. Layer the Pie Crust: Spread half of the peanut butter crumbles evenly across the bottom of the cooled pie crust. This gives a delicious crunchy base under the creamy filling.
3. Prepare Peanut Butter Filling: In a separate bowl, whisk together the instant vanilla pudding mix, milk, and peanut butter for 2 minutes until smooth and slightly thickened. Then, gently fold in the whipped cream or Cool Whip using a spatula, preserving the fluffy texture.
4. Fill the Pie: Pour the peanut butter pudding filling over the peanut butter crumbles in the crust. Smooth the top gently so it’s even.
5. Add Whipped Cream Topping and Garnish: Spread or pipe the remaining 2 cups of whipped cream (or Cool Whip) on top of the pie. Sprinkle the rest of the peanut butter crumbles over the whipped cream as a crunchy, flavorful garnish.
6. Chill to Set: Refrigerate the pie for at least 1 to 2 hours, allowing the pudding to set firmly. This makes slicing neat and keeps the textures perfectly balanced.

How to Serve

Flavor Boosters

Drizzle a bit of melted chocolate over the top or sprinkle crushed roasted peanuts for an extra layer of indulgence. A light dusting of cocoa powder or a few chocolate shavings complement the peanut butter flavor beautifully.

Perfect Pairings

This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe pairs wonderfully with cold milk or a cup of bold coffee. For adults, a scoop alongside a glass of creamy bourbon or peanut butter whiskey adds a nice grown-up twist.

Presentation Touches

Slice the pie with a hot knife (dip the blade in hot water and dry it) for clean cuts. Serving it on pretty dessert plates with a dollop of extra whipped cream and a sprinkle of crumbles turns any occasion into something special. It also makes a heartfelt gift when wrapped carefully in pie boxes for friends and neighbors.

Variations & Easy Swaps

• Use peanut butter powder for a lighter, less oily filling.
• Swap vanilla pudding mix for chocolate for a rich peanut butter chocolate combo.
• Try almond butter or sunflower seed butter for a different nutty twist.
• Make a gluten-free crust for dietary preferences.
• Replace whipped cream topping with coconut whipped cream for a dairy-free pie.
• Add a dollop of caramel sauce on top for extra sweetness.

Make-Ahead, Storage & Reheating

• Prepare pie up to 1 day in advance and keep refrigerated, covered tightly with plastic wrap.
• Store leftovers in the fridge for 3–4 days; the textures soften but flavors stay delightful.
• This pie doesn’t reheat well — serve chilled for best results.
• If pie crust gets soggy over time, consider a no-bake crust next time for longer freshness.

FAQs

Q: Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy?
A: You can, but the crumbles might be chunkier and less consistent. Creamy peanut butter helps the crumbles hold together better.

Q: Do I need to bake the pie crust for this recipe?
A: Yes, a prebaked and cooled crust is best to prevent sogginess and hold all the filling textures nicely.

Q: Can I make this pie vegan or dairy-free?
A: Absolutely. Use plant-based milk, dairy-free pudding mix (check labels), and coconut whipped cream to keep it vegan and dairy-free.

Q: What’s the best way to store leftover Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?
A: Cover it tightly and refrigerate for up to 4 days. Keep it chilled because the filling is pudding-based.

Q: Can I freeze this pie?
A: Freezing isn’t recommended since the whipped cream and pudding texture can become watery when thawed. It’s best enjoyed fresh or refrigerated.

Print